Are you opposed to cashless welfare?
If so, the AUWU strongly encourages you to write a letter saying so to your local member and to the Senate Inquiry into the INDUE welfare card.
Unfortunately, you don’t have much time. The Senate submissions will be closing on September 29 and the vote will be going to the Senate after the inquiry finalises its report on 13 November. We need to put maximum pressure on politicians to vote down the INDUE card.
It’s easier than you think – your letter should be very brief (four pages maximum) and briefly detail some of your concerns about the program.
Here’s a quick four step guide:
Step One: Why Are You Opposed to the Card
Some questions to consider if you have not been on the card:
● How do you see people spending cash and managing their money?
● What goods or services (other than the card’s targets, alcohol & gambling) does/would the card prevent people you work with from accessing?
● Do you think the card has/will have unintended consequences for people and the community?
Some questions to consider if you have been on the card:
● What were/are some of the things you spend cash on?
● Where did/do you spend cash?
● Does/would not having cash effect your budget?
● Does/would not having cash change where you shop?
● What goods or services (other than the card’s targets, alcohol & gambling) does/would the card prevent you from accessing?
● Do you think the card has/will have unintended consequences for people and the community?
● Can you think of any better solutions to problems like addiction than the card?
● How does the card make you feel?
See below for some more information.
Step Two: Introduce Yourself
Politicians needs to know what qualifies you to advise them on the INDUE card and who you are.
For the purposes of the Senate Inquiry you need to tell them how you came to have your knowledge on the card.You also need to directly mention the bill they’re reporting on.
If you’re not sure how to do that it’s okay to copy this sentence below and then finish it by adding relevant detail.
I have knowledge of/information about/familiarity with the Cashless Debit Card that the Social Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2017 would extend because I…
or… As a member of ____________, I have grave concerns about the likely impact of the Cashless Debit Card that the Social Services Legislation Amendment Bill 2017 would extend, because…
For the purposes of writing to your local MP you need to demonstrate who you are and where your are based. Here is a good sample:
“To the Minister / Shadow Minister for Parliament,
My name is _____ and I am based in ____. I am deeply concerned about the Cashless Welfare Card and the legislation currently before the Senate to expand the program.
Even though there have been very negative reports about the effect the card has had on trial communities, the Government seems to be ignoring the people on this issue and increasing the trials in other areas…”
Step Three: Put It All Together
Politicians like it when each different point you make has a heading. In your letter, try to group together all your similar points in a list and put that under a heading.
Some heading examples include:
- “good things about cash”
- “stuff I can’t do on the card”
- “things I worry about”
- “ideas I have”
- “how I feel”
- “things I’ve seen”
- “These are some things I’ve noticed in the community since the Cashless Card was introduced”
You are now ready to send it off.
Step Four: Submit
Contacting your local MP or other politician:
To find your local MP’s email or Minster go here.
Submit to Senate Inquiry:
Go the the Senate Inquiry page for the Social Services Legislation Amendment (Cashless Debit Card) Bill 2017 here and click upload submission. You will need to make an account on My Parliament before you can submit.
Send on your letter to the AUWIU
Please forward your letter onto the AUWU at email@example.com for our record
Why The Cashless Welfare Card is Bad for Business and for Communities:
- Contrary to Government propaganda, the Cashless Welfare card is not as user friendly Government proport it to be. Local and regional communities with high unemployed, single parent and underemployed cohorts mutually support local small business owners by working with them to mutual benefit :https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/may/05/shop-owner-says-cashless-welfare-card-has-left-him-100000-short Both will be negatively impacted by this card.
- The card is produced by the Australian company INDUE, to use it the business owner needs to enter into a business agreement with INDUE which may not benefit the business.
- Small business in regional and rural areas do not necesssarily use Eftpos machines. The cost of small business is climbing, particularly in relation to utilities, the books are getting tighter and every cent counts. There is currently no way for small business owners to quantify how much of their takings is supplied through welfare recipient cash transactions, making a feasibility assessment of wether or not to invest in an eftpos terminal and go into an agreement with INDUE impossible.
- The cashless card is geared towards bigger business such as Coles and Woolies, where shopper anonominity is encouraged, particularly with the installation of Cashier Terminals where no human contact is necessary for a transaction to take place. This means that people who feel stigmatised by the cashless welfare card may choose to stop shopping with small businesses.
- Unsurprisingly these bigger supermarkets are the very same businesses that co-own the Australian Eptpos business, so they stand to take the lions share of Government welfare spending under this card. Australian Eptpos is a company which makes money from transactions and card production, it is wholly owned by its 18 Members so all profits from cashless welfare transactions will go to the following companies:
- Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Limited
- Australian Settlements Limited
- Bank of Queensland Limited
- Bendigo and Adelaide Bank Limited
- Citigroup Pty Limited
- Commonwealth Bank of Australia
- Coles Group Limited
- Cuscal Limited
- First Data Network Australia Limited
- Indue Limited
- ING DIRECT
- National Australia Bank Limited
- PayPal Australia
- Suncorp Bank
- Tyro Payments
- Westpac Banking Corporation
- Woolworths Limited
The many draw backs of the cashless card include:
- The app designed for people to check their account on their smartphone is reported to be glitchy. In areas with poor internet reception the app is a useless utility.
- The INDUE card is very different from a bankcard. It operates as a credit card in the sense that funds are not the property of the recipient, so a recipient has no claim to interest accrued on funds over time. In the case of persons becoming ill and spending a period of time in hospital, (elderly, chronically ill and mental health patients who are unable to access the Disability Support Pension) this can amount to regular periods of many months. Interest accrued on funds becomes a significant revenue stream for the company INDUE who have full ownership of accrued interest across millions of Newstart recipients. In other words INDUE gets to keep the sum total of all your small change, the stuff that goes in the jar above the fridge and comes in handy to pay the winter electricity bill with. This amounts to welfare spending contributing directly to the profit margins of big business, diminishing the growth of smaller local economy.
- The low amount of cash that can be accessed through compulsory income management is not enough to participate in alternate markets such as farmers markets, trash and treasures, local craft markets, alternate food and goods banks and many charity shops which deal exclusively in cash transactions. In regional and rural areas eggs, mulch and fresh vegetables can often be purchased from road side sales points and co-ops dealing only in cash, these healthy options for people on low incomes will be impossible to access with the cashless card.
- The small-economy becomes impossible under income management, how do you pay the babysitter with an INDUE card? How do give $50 to the bloke up the road who fixes your lawn mower or $20 to the boy who mows your lawn if you are unable to? How do you support your children and teenagers to participate in school fates and local excursions that require lunch money, pocket money and taxi money for an emergency such as having no safe option to get home from a late party? How do you teach your kids how to handle cash?
- Residents in Ceduna, one of the trial sites for the Cashless Welfare card have reported their mortgage payments have become more expensive due to added transaction fees.
- People cannot contribute to share house costs with a cashless card. How can you pay your landlord if they only accept cash?
- There are reports that people on income management are begging, are buying food and then reselling it at lower prices to get access to cash so they cover costs like share-room rent, private studio and caravan rent, getting around town using alternate transport systems (throwing in some cash to help with petrol for a friend who gives them a lift somewhere etc) and providing pocket money for their kids, which effectively makes welfare recipients even poorer than they already are.
- Compulsory income management stigmatises people and separates them from mainstream society even further, disallowing social mobility and scapegoating poverty.
- Cheap shopping alternatives such as Aldi are excluded from participating in the scheme because there is no separation between the liquor store and the main store, thus preventing cheap goods being obtainable to people on tight budgets.
- AUWU have information that organised crime gangs are already strategising around how they can recruit a labour force to achieve criminal goals from the pool of unemployed on income management who need access to cash.
- The only people with access to cash in welfare demographics will be elderly pensioners and disability pensioners who will be made vulnerable targets for criminals.
- Cashless welfare, in a society where the welfare payments don’t lift people over the poverty line, forces people to use mainstream shopping outlets that are just too expensive for limited budgets, making emergency situations requiring cash impossible to manage.
- People in welfare demographics will not be able to “chip in” or help each other financially from fortnight to fortnight.
- INDUE are not a bank and cannot provide any of the privacy and security measures that banks provide. Our data will be open to organisations who collect data to profile and target consumers. The Government cannot guarantee our privacy because INDUE are not a Government organisation, regardless of assurances and agreements Government and INDUE come to. This lack of privacy is already an ongoing issue with Job Network Providers who are reported to be repeatedly breaching the privacy rights of their clients.
- There are reports of people manufacturing bootleg liquor because they can no longer by alcohol. The cashless card has already created a back yard market in liquor and gambling in exchange for resalable goods.
- The card will encourage black market labour hire because more people will accept cash work that pays below the minimum wage.